When the curve slipped his grade to a C, this legal studies student sues everyone in sight, citing Stella approved "civil rights violations" and "emotional distress".
Discuss Add this link to...Bury Add to:
| Bookmarks
written by BiteMe 425 days ago - show/hide this comment
Rating: -1
| Rate Comment:+-
I'm afraid I have to disagree
"Marquis got an 84 for the class. But the students' numerical scores struck Cushing as too high, so he graded everyone on a curve before assigning letter grades. Marquis ended up with a C."
"As I am entering grades, I consider whether or not they seem fair," he wrote Marquis. ". . . I thought your grade was a good reflection of your work."
In many ways this speaks for itself.This Marquis had a case alright, and this proves how screwed up the education system really is. On the whim of a teacher he can simply reduce your mark all because he thinks it is too high. Grades should not be subjective, if there is a grading system in place that system should be monitored and controlled, marks are meant to be objective and based on academic performance, if he got an A- based on the university approved grading system used by Cushing then he deserves that A- regardless of Cushing's own feelings towards the work.
written by Dana 425 days ago
Rating: 1
| Rate Comment:+-
Not true, BiteMe--lots of times subjective factors play into grades. How, for example, would you objectively mark the "class participation" portion? Count the number of minutes the student spoke? Perhaps in this case the student was clearly good at spitting back answers, but didn't demonstrate true comprehension. We can't know what went on during the course of the class.
I personally don't think teachers should grade on curves--each student's performance should stand on its own--but it's not illegal. And it's certainly not inappropriate for an instructor to use his judgment in assigning a grade.
written by twinhound 425 days ago
Rating: 1
| Rate Comment:+-
"Problems In Social Thought" was the course title. Mr. Marquis adolescent behavior leads me to believe he probably didn't learn much in this class, if anything, substantial. Perhaps he may gain some insight by looking in a mirror... Then again, probably not.
A philosophy class is incredibly difficult to grade in a completely "objective" manner, unlike mathematics or computer science. As a former college instructor (and lifelong student) I have to agree with Mr. Cushing's decision to grade the last exam more critically. Students are expected to retain previous lessons and build on them during a semester.
The grade of 84 speaks for itself. In the various schools I have been associated with, both as faculty and student, an 84=C, period.
Mr. Marquis inability to learn how to write for a Philosophy class over the course of a semester should be a concern for potential law schools, raising the question about whether or not he can compose an effective and logical argument for the court.
Comments
Not true, BiteMe--lots of times subjective factors play into grades. How, for example, would you objectively mark the "class participation" portion? Count the number of minutes the student spoke? Perhaps in this case the student was clearly good at spitting back answers, but didn't demonstrate true comprehension. We can't know what went on during the course of the class.
I personally don't think teachers should grade on curves--each student's performance should stand on its own--but it's not illegal. And it's certainly not inappropriate for an instructor to use his judgment in assigning a grade.
"Problems In Social Thought" was the course title. Mr. Marquis adolescent behavior leads me to believe he probably didn't learn much in this class, if anything, substantial. Perhaps he may gain some insight by looking in a mirror... Then again, probably not.
A philosophy class is incredibly difficult to grade in a completely "objective" manner, unlike mathematics or computer science. As a former college instructor (and lifelong student) I have to agree with Mr. Cushing's decision to grade the last exam more critically. Students are expected to retain previous lessons and build on them during a semester.
The grade of 84 speaks for itself. In the various schools I have been associated with, both as faculty and student, an 84=C, period.
Mr. Marquis inability to learn how to write for a Philosophy class over the course of a semester should be a concern for potential law schools, raising the question about whether or not he can compose an effective and logical argument for the court.